Thread:OBWforumsContentRevision/@comment-34674756-20181112170842/@comment-34674756-20181115132822

SuperBearNeo X wrote: strictly from Creepypasta Wiki, Slenderman Wiki and the official SCP Foundation page." Your not understanding the rules themselves and are taking them too literal.

You aren't understanding your own rules or you shouldn't have used "strictly".

>"Fan-Made" stories are in referrence to obvious fanfiction fluff that's trollpasta quality and seeks an attempt to make characters more powerful. They are disregarded moreso on the fact that they break consistency as opposed to their bad quality (Which doesn't help)

'''Fan-Made merely means fan made, as in not created by the orginal author. So Slenderman vs Jeff breaks consistancy but it is fine because you say it is. Well do you know what is fanfic? All the creepypasta themed characters living together and yet we have two profiles from that premise. Well also have profiles which would be on fanfiction.net due to incorperating lisensed charaters, giving them bloody eyes or saying they are evil and then saying "it is original". Also going by fanfic and bad quality Eyless Jack and Jeff (As well as anyone connected to them) shouldn't even be here.'''

>Yes. It does further support the idea of a multiverse, especially when most creators consider things just alternate realities as opposed to just outright never happened. Furthermore you can't just ignore the fact Creepypasta is stated to be a multiverse numerous times.

'''I am not ignoring the fact that stories under the horror genere are said to be multiverses, it is you ignoring the fact that these stories have no connection besides what "genre" you say they are in. It doesn't make sense to do that, except that you are considering fan works and fanfics as canon.'''

It's a multiverse because everything happened but not everything is connected to the same universe. By definition a Multiverse. This is ingoring the times it was established Creepypasta is actually a Infinite Multiverse. Something not falling within a author's line doesn't invadate something with the nature of Creepypasta, because it's a genre and not an entire product that someone has control over

Just because they share a genre doesn't mean they are a connected work.

>That statement is hypocritial is because you considered SCP Foundation connected. It doesn't matter how many imaginary dots you connect, it's still allowing writers to add anything to SCP Foundation just with restrictions and people allowing what can or can't appear. That's the only difference between Creepypasta and SCP Foundation, nothing else, so acting like it's different is by definition hypocritial.

'''Then both should be either cleaned up or deleted. SCP should likely only follow the original page like Creepypasta should only follow the original story.'''

>False Equalivence. Marvel isn't a genre, it's a product that falls under a genre. That argument doesn't work because the very idea of Marvel is governed by people who trademark and have full control over it. So it's different from Creepypasta, which is a genre where no one person has control

'''Sir, I am meaning as an example not a equlization. I am meaning it as an overblown example of what you are doing on a higfher scale so the point is easily visible. Again, if it is a genre then it doesn't mean they are connected. They aren't. Many CP writers don't consider their works cannon to a nonexistant connected universe.'''

Besides if I am completely honest this thread will likely change nothing. No will notice this and those who do likely don't care enough. Still you are very knowlegable and I understand your thought prosesses, but I highly disagree with it. Connecting unconnected stories just because they are in a gerne just is wrong. They aren't connected stories, there is no Slender Masion except in fanfics, Jeff never fought Slenderman, EJ isn't a proxy, etc.