Thread:OBWforumsContentRevision/@comment-34674756-20181112170842/@comment-34674756-20181114125123

'''SBN=This wikia has already heard this argument and has refuted this. It doesn't go against the rules as sources are from Creepypasta Wikia or sites comparable in reliability to them. These feats don't come from Fanfiction.net and shit, so this falls within our rules of measuring extended universe Creepypasta characters.'''

Headless=Link to the refutement will be needed. And yes it does when the rule is:This is the most basic form of scaling however note that said feats have to be consistent with the characters and what said character have been consistently shown also no fanfiction or fan-made stories allowed with these characters we are using sources strictly from Creepypasta Wiki, Slenderman Wiki and the official SCP Foundation page.

'''SBN=The second half doesn't prove Creepypasta isn't connected. The creator of Jeff The Killer actually considers everything connected and part of the same reality. Just not canon to his original work for obvious reasons. Eyeless Jack should probably have a Extended Universe tab as welll because that comes from the extended canon'''

Headless=So just because one creator thought some fanfic is ok, and that he "likes to think of it as an AU", that means it is canon and that all creepypastas are in a universe that is a multiverse. No that doesn't make sense, and further more in a interveiw with the creator of JTK he considers his own creation not creepypasta anyway.

'''SBN=The entity that represents Mr.Creepypasta has appeared and been referred many times in Creepypasta. The fact he exists in Creepypasta is what makes him a character'''

Headless=Links needed to the many times.

'''SBN=No it doesn't. Creepypasta itself is a multiverse and all stories are considered just events that happened but not in the same universe. Unless they have a explicit connection. Even the creator of Jeff The Killer runs on this principle and so does the admin of Creepypasta. So obviously this happened but not in the original universe the character is set in'''

Headless=Then why are you saying it is a multiverse when there is no connection? Also are you going with the quote where he likes to think of other versions of his character as "AUs"? Cause why would you take that statement and say it aplies to all Creepypasta?

'SBN=Well....Creepypasta is a genre and nothing is really considered more canon than another thing. They simply all happened'

''Headless=If there is no canon then why do we have the verse when literal anyone can add to it and it will not be considered fanfic (to you) as long as they don't post it on a fanfic sight. The defintion of fanfic is: ''fiction written by a fan of, and featuring characters from, a particular TV series, movie, etc. That would include people who didn't orginally make the charater. Writing not done by the creator is by defintion, fanfic. Saying "They simply happened" is like me making Ironman and Capt. America a gay couple corrupted by satan and due to Marvel's multivere saying "It must have happened", and then a random Marvel company working just tweeting out "I like it". That doesn't make the fanfic canon. It just means the creator liked it.