Thread:OBWforumsContentRevision/@comment-35910999-20190813204735

So, I have a couple of problems with the Creepypasta profiles. So, lets go through those problems.

Town Level AP

We can start off with the basis by which characters are town level. That being Slenderman.

"Town Level (Was capable of burning down a forest with pure strength)"

>How on earth does one burn down a forest with pure strength? It's far more likely that Slenderman simply burnt down a forest. All that shows is fire manipulation, not some sort of town level attack potency. The characters this would change would be: Joice Blackwell, Slenderman, Jeff The Killer and The Puppeteer. All of these should either be downgraded to unknown or should be placed at a different level if you have different feats.

Scaling Problems

"Destructive Ability: Wall Level (As a proxy of Slenderman, he should be vastly superior to that of Jeff The Killer and Jane The Killer due to having a small portion of his power within him)"

>Jeff never was a proxy of Slenderman in the original story, therefore this is based off of the extended universe version of Jeff The Killer. Therefore, Ticci Toby should be stronger than 9-B. This would also apply to Zachariah Smith, Eyeless Jack, and Judge Angel.

"Town Level (Shouldn’t be too far behind Slenderman)"

>I've already discussed the problems with town level Slenderman, but how does the Rake scale to Slenderman? Is there anything which suggests this?

Outdated Justifications

"Far stronger than Laughing Jack, who is atleast comparable to The Proxies"

>Laughing Jack now has an unknown rating in his AP, and how does he scale to The Proxies in anyway?

On High 1-B Zalgo

As we can see here, the Incantation clearly speaks of Zalgo in the third person.

https://thecreepypastas.fandom.com/wiki/Zalgo%27s_Incanation

Yet, in the latin translation we see Zalgo being referred to in the first person

https://vignette.wikia.nocookie.net/omniversal-battlefield/images/9/9e/Zalgo_Will_Unmake_All.jpg/revision/latest/scale-to-width-down/380?cb=20171230032923

We can therefore conclude that this is not an accurate translation, and therefore Zalgo shouldn't have his attack potency scaled to this latin translation

Jeff The Killer

"Stamina:Extremely High (Can still stand against Slenderman for a very long time)"

>The problem with this is that Jeff didn't contend with Slenderman in the original story, yet the author seemingly puts one key for his stamina implying that he fought Slenderman in the original story and therefore his stamina can scale. That's not true, so Jeff should have two stamina keys.

"Intelligence: Supergenius (Should be at this level due to peak human condition, which includes intelligence)"

>Just because one is peak human physically does not at all mean that one is peak human mentally. Even ignoring that, it's still flawed. Super genius individuals have extremely high superhuman levels of intelligence, and therefore Jeff wouldn't have super genius intelligence even if we accepted the faulty premise.

"Lifting Ability: Likely Athletic Human, possibly Peak Human (Based on striking strength)"

>One does not scale lifting strength to striking strength unless that lifting strength is the basis for one's striking strength, which isn't the case with Jeff.

So, that's my post. 